A. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Maher, Ramona. 2003. ALICA YAZZIE’S YEAR. Berkeley, California: Tricycle Press. Illustrated by Shonto Begay. ISBN 582460809.
B. PLOT SUMMARY
An eleven year old Navajo girl narrates each month of a year in her life growing up in modern-day American on a reservation.
C. CRITICAL ANALYSIS (INCLUDLING CULTURAL MARKERS)
Maher captures the year of Alice, a Navajo eleven year old, in a slow moving format. The pace moves so slowly that most young readers will probably put this book down after reading a few pages. Instruction by teachers will be needed for students to gain a deeper understanding of the material. Many Native American elements are seen in Maher’s writing. She mentions many important Navajo elements, like sheepskin, pinyon wood and frybread. Alice also attends school off the reservation and goes on field trips to experience more culture, particularly white culture like Disneyland. Even though she enjoyed the trip, she was quick to point out that “nobody listened and the nicest thing was coming back here.”
Alice is proud of her Native American culture and wears squash blossom and turquoise jewelry. The coyote is also seen as a very important animal to Alice and her friends. When she adopts a coyote pup she writes, “It is her friend and is named for a friend.” The grandfather character incorporates traditional Native American role by riding a horse and wearing a headband but he also values education and wants the Navajo children to learn technology. The grandfather’s choices could be discussed by readers as whether he is evolving like other Native Americans have had to or feeling pressured to change by the white man.
Maher captures some of the Native American discontent with white people by her text. Some examples are, “Strip mined for power-the kind of power that white people know” and Alice is bothered by the white preacher’s wife pressuring her to attend Sunday school. The story of Thanksgiving and how it can mean something else to Native Americans is highlighted in the month of November. Alice tells her teacher, “We’d be glad to see Columbus sail away.”
Alice also embraces living in a modern world, as much as having traditional Navajo elements to her life. She dresses up as Australian 1980s tennis star, Evonne Goolagong, for Halloween and gives her grandfather Mickey Mouse ears. Fortunately, her grandfather seems to enjoy how Alice incorporates all cultures into their life by statements like, “Evonne Goolagong. I like that name.”
The afterword by Navajo educator Carl Gorman is important for readers. He explains the Navajo translations that are next to each month of the year. It is not a literal translation of the month like most readers probably assumed but more a little phrase about that time of the year. These explanations help the reader understand Navajo culture better.
Begay’s illustrations are vivid and bright. Native American elements are very abundant throughout the book. Alice and her grandfather are dark skinned and their hair is very dark, almost blue-black. Alice also wears her hair in traditional braids and her grandfather has a long ponytail. They both wear traditional Native American jewelry with silver and turquoise. Southwest American animals like buffalo, horses and coyote are also depicted.
D. REVIEW EXCERPTS“… Clearly meant for older readers despite the picture-book format, the book compares a buffalo's eyes to "a drunk bronc rider's," which may make the intended audience even less certain. Begay's illustrations are wonderfully textured and infused with the colors of the Southwest. For some children, the artwork may be more revealing of traditional Navajo lifestyles than the pared down, almost stream-of-consciousness text. Purchase where supplemental materials on Native American culture are needed.” SCHOOL LIBRARY JOURNAL
“…At times, Alice's perspective is political (she speaks out against Columbus in school); at other times it is lyrical (lightning is "ghosts chasing their tails"). Begay's paintings, impressionistic dabs and swirls of brilliant color, sometimes muddy faces and expressions, but like the words, the wild patterns and hues leave room for imaginations to fill in the spaces. Whether read alone or aloud, the poems tell an affecting story about contemporary Navajo life through an appealing young character with a strong sense of history and herself. Teachers will want to use this across the curriculum; a concluding section offers more background to Navajo language and culture.” BOOKLIST
E. CONNECTIONS
Visit Shonto Begay’s website, www.shontobegay.com and learn more about the artist’s background. Discuss how his life as a Native American shaped his art.
Pick out Native American terms and create a glossary for the book.
No comments:
Post a Comment